Harvesting Organs Essay - 723 Words

Is it wrong to take Baby Teresas life so she can donate her organs to others in need even though she can only live for a few days? Although some might argue that it is morally wrong to take an innocent persons life, she could be saving many others lives by donating her organs. I will be defending the Benefits Argument in this paper, and I will argue that transplanting the organs will indeed benefit other children. I will first present a general overview of the Baby Teresa case, and then I will present the facts to my Benefits Argument. I will then present an opposing argument, how someone would attack my views, and then I will defend my argument from the objection. Finally, in the conclusion I will give certain highlights and†¦show more content†¦Baby Teresa died 9 days after her birth and because her organs were so badly deteriorated, it was too late for other children because her organs could not be transplanted. (Rachels, pg. 1-2) My argument for the transplant of her organs is the Benefits Argument. My view is that because Baby Teresa was going to die soon and the transplant would not cause her pain because her brain is missing, her organs were doing her no good. She would not be able to have a life even if she did survive, carry on any activities, have thoughts, feelings, and relations with other people. In contrast, if she would gain from keeping her life, then transplanting her organs would be wrong. My argument is as follows: Since the transplant can benefit someone without harming others, we ought to do so. The organs would certainly benefit others without harming Baby Teresa, so therefore we should take her organs. This argument is sound because the premises are true and the conclusion logically follows the premise. It is important that the intention of the transplant is to benefit other children; otherwise taking Baby Teresas life would be wrong. (Rachels, pg. 3) An objection to my argument would be that although we assume that Baby Teresas organs can help benefit others, what if it cannot? My Benefits Argument will show to be invalid if her organs or blood type did not match any recipients. It is unlikely that her organs or blood type do not match, but there is that possibility.Show MoreRelatedOrgan Harvesting in China Essay1401 Words   |  6 Pagesin 2006 laid this caption under a photo he had taken to support his article. It was reported in the article how executed prisoners had become the primary source of body organ transplants. Still to this day in China, organs are being removed from the bodies of Falun prisoners without consent from anyone, to be used as donor organs for patients in need. The moment they find someone in need, the prisoners are immediately made victims. The process works something like this: In China, the hospital notifiesRead MoreBlack Market Organ Harvesting: Is it Truly Inevitable?1619 Words   |  7 Pagesfor human tissue and bodily fluids. Human tissues are a product in high demand with little supply. People ask if there is a way to stop this. There is not. The black market trade in organs, bones, blood, and plasma is inevitable due to the ambiguity surrounding organ donation and transplant laws, a shortage of organ donors, and the lucrative nature of selling human tissues. Law and economics recognize three types of markets with varying degrees of legality: white, gray, and black. The trade inRead MoreHarvesting Baby Theresas Organs: Arguments and Ethics2887 Words   |  12 PagesEthics James Rachels says that one of the arguments given against harvesting Baby Theresas organs is The Argument That We Should Not Use People as Means. What is this argument and in what ways does it rely on deontological ideas and principles? The argument that we should not use people as means is very significant. It is focused on using things and not people. In other words, it is very important to treat people the way we would want to be treated instead of seeing them as disposable commoditiesRead MorePersuasive Essay On Human Cloning1106 Words   |  5 Pagesopinion, the research on human cloning should be a priority because of its incredible benefits in advancing the process of human evolution, an opportunity mankind to restart their incomplete life, and encouraging reproductive technologies, such as organ transplants. This innovation will direct human history into a new era, one without the limit of time, furthering human abilities. The first benefit of human cloning is the advancement of the process of human evolution. Humans have developed both physicallyRead MoreOrgan Shortage Around The World2101 Words   |  9 PagesIn the 21st century, it is obvious to the world that there is an organ shortage around the world. Many thousands, hundreds of thousands of people are waiting for organs to save their lives. There are just not enough organs to be spread around to the people who urgently need them. The global response to this problem is very different throughout different countries. Some countries are harvesting organs, some executing prisoners, some paying people to donate, some allowing people to sell them on theRead MoreHuman Organs Should Not Be a Comodity583 Words   |  2 Pagesis no question that organ transplants are capable of saving countless lives. However, a problem exists because there are not enough organs available to meet the existing need. The buying of human organs is illegal around the world, and this has resulted in the creation of the black market. There is currently a debate on whether the business of organ transplants on the open market should be legal. Transplants should be illegal because only the wealthy can afford to buy organs ;they should be donatedRead MoreOrgan Trafficking Essay1551 Words   |  7 Pagestotal, Im worth about $300,000 on the organ market. The organ trade is one of the fastest growing and least enforced trafficking crimes throughout the globe today (Glazer 341). Sarah Glazer claims in Organ Trafficking that 5,000 to 10,000 of the 100,000 transplanted organs are obtained illegally each year (341). Although the laws passed and organizations founded have delayed the escalation of organ trafficking, the selling and distribution of compensated organs should remain illegal and suppressedRead MoreEconomics And Ethics Of Alternative Cadaveric Organ Procurement Policies1901 Words   |  8 PagesAlternative Cadaveric Organ Procurement Policies,â₠¬  Roger Blair and David Kaserman are trying to persuade those in the medical field to stop using the current system of organ harvesting and adopt a new system. Blair and Kaserman, throughout the whole article, are trying to persuade those interested to adopt a new policy. As it blatantly states in the title of the article, they also discuss the economical and ethical dilemmas that are causing the shortage in organ harvesting and exploring new waysRead MoreTaking a Look at Nephropathy1818 Words   |  7 Pagesknow that he did all that waiting only to die after finally getting a new kidney. I don’t know if having the sale of human organs legal at the time my grandfather was alive could have saved his life. But for all that time that my grandfather had to wait to get a new kidney, it should be legal to sell human organs. If done in the right way of course. I think the sale of human organs has great repercussions on society and the human body. There is a great possibility that we may begin to be viewed as commoditiesRead MoreOrgan Trafficking : A Large Problem1446 Words   |  6 PagesIllegal organ trafficking has become a large problem all over the world. The traffickers are commonly attacking the poor and promising them money but it never ends up being the correct amount. Commonly doctors and pharmaceutical companies overlook the illegal trade of the organs because they receiving money from the transplants. Organ trafficking takes place in three broad categories. The first one is organ traffickers will force or trick the individual into giving up an organ. Secondly the victim